← Blog

Keeping your old home as a rental: how Fannie Mae mortgage rules count the rent

Buying your next home and keeping the old one as a rental? A worksheet for how Fannie Mae counts the old home's rent, the reserve test, documents and a pre-application timeline.

If you buy a new home with a Fannie Mae loan and keep your current home as a rental, the lender counts that home's rent in a fixed way. It takes 75% of the home's market rent and subtracts the home's full monthly payment (principal, interest, taxes, insurance and association dues, or PITIA). If the result is positive, it cancels the old payment out of your debt-to-income ratio, but it never adds to your income. If it is negative, the shortfall is added to your monthly debts. A signed lease cannot be used, and if you have less than 12 months of landlord experience you also need six months of the old home's PITIA in reserves.

These rules come from Fannie Mae Selling Guide B3-3.8-05, dated September 2, 2026. Under Announcement SEL-2026-08, lenders may use the rewritten rental income rules now and must use them for loan applications dated on or after December 1, 2026.

This guide is for salaried professionals who are buying their next home and want to keep the current one as their first or next rental. It was checked against the live Selling Guide on November 18, 2026. It covers Fannie Mae only. FHA, VA, Freddie Mac and portfolio lenders use their own rules, and individual lenders can add stricter requirements (called overlays). This is general education, not lending advice. For the wider rule set, including short-term rentals and lease standards, see the Fannie Mae rental income guide.

What counts as a departing residence

Fannie Mae treats a home as a departing residence when it is your primary residence today, you will move out, and you will convert it to an investment property when you buy a new primary residence. It is the home you are leaving, not the one you are buying.

Three things follow from that label:

  • The lender uses market rent, not a lease. The guide says lease agreements are not permitted for any departing residence. Rent must come from a full appraisal that includes market rents, a Single-Family Comparable Rent Schedule (Form 1007), or market tools such as Zillow, Redfin or the MLS with at least three comparable rentals, ideally from the same subdivision or project.
  • Positive rent only offsets that home's payment. This holds even if you already own other rentals and have years of landlord experience.
  • You must have a current housing payment. The lender has to document what you pay for the home you live in today before it can use any rent from it. For a mortgaged home that payment usually appears on your credit report.

If you plan to keep the old home as a second home instead, none of this rent math applies. Under B3-6-06, the full PITIA of a second home counts as a monthly debt.

The worksheet, step by step

Run these seven steps before you talk to a lender. They show roughly where your debt-to-income ratio (DTI) will land. The lender's numbers decide the actual result.

Step What to do Where the figure comes from
1. Old home PITIA Add principal and interest, property taxes, homeowners or landlord insurance, and HOA or condo dues Mortgage statement, tax bill, insurance declarations page, HOA statement
2. Market rent Estimate monthly rent from at least three comparable rentals nearby Your own research now; the lender's appraisal, Form 1007 or market tools later
3. Net rent Market rent × 75% Fannie Mae's fixed vacancy and maintenance factor
4. ANRI Net rent minus old home PITIA Fannie Mae calls this adjusted monthly net rental income
5. Effect on debts If ANRI is zero or positive, add $0. If negative, add the shortfall to monthly debts B3-3.8-05 and B3-3.8-01
6. DTI (New home PITIA + other monthly debts + any shortfall) ÷ gross monthly income Your pay stubs and credit report
7. Reserve test Under 12 months of landlord experience: hold six months of old home PITIA in reserves B3-3.8-05

A shortcut for step 4: the old home breaks even when market rent equals its PITIA divided by 0.75. A home with a $2,100 PITIA needs about $2,800 of market rent before the rent fully cancels the payment.

If your insurance will switch to a landlord policy after you move out, get a quote before you apply and ask the lender which premium it will use. The landlord insurance vs homeowners insurance guide explains the difference between the two policies.

Hypothetical example: when the rent falls short and when it covers

Every figure below is invented to show the math. None of it describes a real borrower, property or loan.

A borrower earns $11,000 a month before tax and has $400 in other monthly debts, such as a car loan. The new home's PITIA will be $3,200. The home they are leaving has a PITIA of $2,100.

Step Scenario A: market rent $2,600 Scenario B: market rent $3,000
Net rent (× 75%) $1,950 $2,250
ANRI (net rent − $2,100) −$150 +$150
Added to monthly debts $150 $0
Added to income $0 $0 (positive rent only offsets the old payment)
Total monthly debts ($3,200 + $400 + shortfall) $3,750 $3,600
DTI (debts ÷ $11,000) 34.1% 32.7%

For comparison, if no rent counted at all, the old home's full $2,100 would sit in debts. DTI would be ($3,200 + $400 + $2,100) ÷ $11,000 = 51.8%. That gap is why the rent rule matters so much to people buying their next home.

Notice that the extra $150 in Scenario B does not help the borrower qualify. Higher rent above the break-even point improves the property's cash flow, not the loan application.

The reserve test in the same example

If the borrower has never been a landlord, they also need six months of the old home's PITIA in reserves: 6 × $2,100 = $12,600. That is on top of any other reserves the loan requires. Reserves are liquid assets left after closing, such as checking, savings and investment accounts or the vested part of a retirement account, under B3-4.1-01. Your down payment and closing costs come out first.

How landlord experience changes the result

Fannie Mae asks for at least 12 months of property management experience before positive rent can raise qualifying income on rentals in general (B3-3.8-01). Lenders usually prove it with your latest signed Form 1040, including Schedules 1 and E, showing a property rented for 365 fair rental days.

For a departing residence, experience changes only the reserve test:

Under 12 months of experience 12 months or more
How rent is counted 75% of market rent minus PITIA Same
Positive result Offsets the old home's PITIA only Offsets the old home's PITIA only
Negative result Added to monthly debts Added to monthly debts
Extra reserves for the old home Six months of its PITIA Not required by this rule

If you already own other financed rentals, Fannie Mae has separate reserve rules for multiple financed properties, and the how many mortgages can you have guide covers the property count limits.

If the old home is a duplex, triplex or fourplex

If you live in one unit of a two- to four-unit building and are moving out, the rules split by unit. The market rent analysis covers only the unit you live in, and the 75% factor applies only to that unit. Units that already have tenants follow the rules for other rentals you own in B3-3.8-04, and the lender must get your most recent Form 1040 to support the rent those units produce. The house hacking guide covers how this kind of property works day to day.

Documents checklist

Gather these before you apply. Your lender may ask for more.

  1. The old home's latest mortgage statement, showing principal, interest and any escrow for taxes and insurance.
  2. The property tax bill, insurance declarations page and any HOA or condo statement for the old home, if they are not escrowed.
  3. Proof of your current housing payment if it is not on your credit report: six months of bank statements or cancelled checks, or the latest property tax bill for a home you own outright.
  4. Your own list of three or more comparable rentals near the old home. The lender will set market rent from its appraisal, Form 1007 or market tools, but your list helps you spot a low estimate early.
  5. Your latest signed Form 1040 with Schedules 1 and E if you already own a rental and want to show 12 months of experience.
  6. Asset statements that cover six months of the old home's PITIA after down payment and closing costs, if you have less than 12 months of experience.
  7. Your latest Form 1040 showing rent from tenant-occupied units, if the old home is a two- to four-unit building.
  8. A landlord insurance quote if your policy will change when you move out.

What not to rely on: a newly signed lease or a tenant's deposit. You may still want a lease in place for practical reasons, but the lender cannot use it to set qualifying rent on a departing residence.

Pre-application timeline

  • Three months or more before applying: Add up the old home's PITIA, pull comparable rentals and work out the break-even rent. If the result is negative, test whether your DTI still works with the shortfall added.
  • Two to three months before: Count your landlord experience. If you have under 12 months, check that your savings can cover six months of the old home's PITIA after the down payment and closing costs.
  • One to two months before: Ask lenders which version of the rental income rules they use today and whether they add overlays on departing residences. The questions to ask a mortgage lender list is a good place to add those two. Get the landlord insurance quote.
  • At application: Tell the lender the old home will become a rental, so it is treated as a departing residence rather than a second home or a pending sale.

When the numbers do not work

If the old home's rent cannot carry its payment and the shortfall pushes your DTI too high, you have a few routes to compare with your lender:

  • Sell instead of keeping it. Under B3-6-06, if the old home is under contract but will not close before your new loan, the lender can leave its PITIA out when you provide the executed sales contract and confirmation that any financing contingencies have been cleared.
  • Ask about another loan program. FHA, VA, Freddie Mac and portfolio lenders treat departing residences differently. The rental property loans guide and the financing hub compare the main options.
  • Check the long-term fit. Keeping a former home as a rental is an investment decision, not just a loan question. The second home vs investment property guide covers how the two uses differ.

Selling a former home has its own tax timing, which this guide does not cover. The selling a rental property guide is a starting point. Talk to a tax professional before you decide.

Common questions

Can rent from my old home help me qualify for a bigger loan?

Only up to a point. Under Fannie Mae's departing residence rule, positive rent can cancel the old home's PITIA out of your debts, but it never adds to your income. Rent above the break-even level does not raise how much you can borrow.

Do I need a tenant or a signed lease before closing?

Not for qualifying. Lenders cannot use a lease for a departing residence. They set rent from an appraisal with market rents, Form 1007, or market tools with at least three comparable rentals.

What if I have never been a landlord?

The rent math is the same, but you also need six months of the old home's PITIA in reserves, in addition to any other reserves the loan requires.

What if I keep the old home as a second home instead?

Then it is not a departing residence for rental income purposes. Fannie Mae counts a second home's full PITIA as a monthly debt.

When do these rules apply?

The departing residence section is dated September 2, 2026. Lenders may use the rewritten rules now and must use them for applications dated on or after December 1, 2026. Ask your lender which version applies to your application.

Do FHA or VA loans follow the same rule?

No. This guide covers Fannie Mae's Selling Guide only. FHA, VA, Freddie Mac and portfolio lenders set their own departing residence rules, so ask your lender which guide your loan follows.

Sources checked November 18, 2026: B3-3.8-05 Departing Residence, B3-3.8-01 General Rental Income Information, B3-3.8-04 Non-Subject Property, B3-6-06 Other Real Estate Owned, B3-4.1-01 Minimum Reserve Requirements and Announcement SEL-2026-08. Fannie Mae updates its guide often, so confirm the current version with your lender.

Keep reading